1 week ago
4
ARTICLE AD BOX
NEW YORK -- Daniel Penny has been recovered not blameworthy of criminally negligent homicide for the decease of Jordan Neely by the assemblage connected Monday.
The assemblage deliberated for much than 24 hours crossed 5 days earlier reaching the verdict.
The assemblage successful the Penny proceedings continued deliberations Monday implicit whether helium committed criminally negligent homicide erstwhile helium placed Neely successful a chokehold connected a subway car past year, aft the assemblage was deadlocked connected the much superior complaint of manslaughter past week.
At the petition of prosecutors connected Friday, Judge Maxwell Wiley dismissed the second-degree manslaughter complaint - which carried a maximum 15-year condemnation - and directed the assemblage to crook to the lesser complaint of criminally negligent homicide, which has a four-year maximum sentence. Neither transgression has a minimum sentence. Penny pleaded not blameworthy to some charges.
"What that means is you are present escaped to see number two. Whether that makes immoderate quality oregon not, I person nary idea," Wiley said earlier sending the assemblage location for the weekend.
Prosecutors allege that Penny killed Neely, a 30-year-old stateless antheral who had antecedently been a Michael Jackson impersonator, erstwhile helium placed him successful a six-minute-long chokehold connected a subway car successful May 2023, holding Neely for astatine slightest 51 seconds aft his assemblage went limp. Assistant territory lawyer Dafna Yoran argued Penny knew his actions could termination Neely but continued to clasp him successful a chokehold for "way excessively long" and "didn't admit his humanity."
The city's aesculapian examiner concluded Penny's chokehold killed Neely. The defence argued Neely died from a familial information and the synthetic marijuana recovered successful his system.
Defense lawyer Steven Raiser told jurors that Penny "acted to save" subway passengers from a "violent and desperate" Neely, who was acting erratically and "scared the surviving daylights retired of everybody." Raiser argued that Neely was warring back, and Penny continued to clasp connected due to the fact that helium feared helium would interruption free, though helium didn't mean to termination Neely.
Wiley denied a caller question for a mistrial made Monday greeting by Penny's defence lawyers, who argued that the dismissal of the manslaughter complaint would power the jury's verdict.
"There is nary mode to cure the ineligible mistake that we judge precise powerfully happened connected Friday, and we are renewing our question for a mistrial connected the remaining number two," said Thomas Kenniff, who said the dismissal could effect successful a "coercive verdict."
Wiley disagreed, promptly denying the question similar helium did connected Friday erstwhile the defence unsuccessfully argued doubly for a mistrial.
To forestall the anticipation of influencing the jury, Wiley projected issuing a caller acquisition to the assemblage explicitly stating that the tribunal is "not directing you to immoderate peculiar verdict."
Wiley besides offered to springiness the assemblage an acquisition to disregard chants from protesters extracurricular the courthouse - including "Justice for Jordan Neely," "Daniel Penny subway stranger" and "If we don't get nary justice, they don't get nary peace" - which the defence squad declined due to the fact that it mightiness bring much attraction to the chants.
For now, the chants person quieted down, and they are nary longer audible successful court. If they resume, Judge Wiley said helium would see delivering an acquisition oregon moving the assemblage to different deliberation room.
Last week, the assemblage spent much than 23 hours crossed 4 days deliberating whether Penny, a 26-year-old erstwhile Marine and architecture student, committed 2nd grade manslaughter earlier repeatedly signaling that they could not scope a unanimous verdict.
Wiley yet granted prosecutors' petition to disregard the archetypal number portion Penny's defence attorneys unsuccessfully pushed for a mistrial, arguing that continued deliberations could pb to a "coercive oregon a compromised verdict" by "elbowing" jurors to convict connected the lesser charge.
Manslaughter would person required proving that Penny acted recklessly and grossly deviated from however a tenable idiosyncratic would behave, portion proving criminally negligent homicide requires the assemblage to beryllium convinced that Penny engaged successful "blameworthy conduct" that helium did not see would pb to the hazard of death.
Outside court, protesters and antagonistic protesters person assembled, with "say his name" chants somewhat audible successful the 13th level courtroom. As Penny entered the courthouse this morning, helium was met with competing chants of "murderer" and "not guilty."
Copyright © 2024 KFSN-TV. All Rights Reserved.
